Balanced reporting on the famine in Gaza must include sources other than COGAT
"To include COGAT’s response but omit the original IPC report is unfair. Readers are left without reference to the essential document that is relevant to this discussion. To meet CBC’s fundamental principle of balance, reference to the report and a short description of its findings must be included in your article."
Read moreArticle about the March 30 pro-Palestine protest in Toronto fails to include voices from protesters and organizers
"It is your journalistic obligation to include voices from the protesters and organizers themselves to balance the record. Please include voices from protesters, PYM, and Jews Say No To Genocide and shed light on the issue of Canada’s police brutality."
Read moreFor Global News, the burden of proof falls on everyone but Israel
"I find it puzzling and deeply disturbing that Global News could, in good conscience, piece together a news segment that goes from footage of a battered, hollowed, and burned Al-Shifa hospital to Israeli army footage of their justification for their attacks: three guns scattered on the floor."
Read moreOverwhelmingly citing Toronto Police doesn't make an article balanced
"Please include voices from protesters and PYM. Otherwise, it makes it seem like the protesters were provoking Toronto Police and that its excessive use of force and arrests were justified. It inserts itself in a media trend seeking to depict the pro-Palestine protests and protesters as violent."
Read moreL'article utilise un langage qui minimise la brutalité de la situation à Gaza et la responsabilité d'Israël
"Ce langage nébuleux peut porter à confusion vos lecteurs alors qu’il insinue une symétrie de pouvoir entre le Hamas et Israël et que les victimes sont autant Israéliennes que Palestiniennes ce qui n’est pas le cas."
Read moreCBC News edits title of segment following our complaints
On March 15, 2024, CJPME sent a letter to CBC News, pushing the media outlet to make some changes in a segment about the group of Israelis blockading humanitarian aid from entering Gaza. Originally titled “Israeli civilians protest Gaza aid deliveries,” the segment presents the blockaders as harmless and benevolent, which is entirely inappropriate considering the nature of their acts. The Israelis are not “protesting” humanitarian aid entering Gaza, they are actively blockading humanitarian aid from entering Gaza. While CJPME made several demands, which can be found in the original letter sent to CBC’s team, the outlet just opted to change the word “protest” to “target” and edit the title to “Israeli protestors target Gaza aid deliveries.”
Article is a platform for NECA
It is concerning that such an article is labeled as news, although it does not provide any perspectives other than those of the Network of Engaged Canadian Academics (NECA), especially Deidre Butler, its co-chair. This article is a platform for their views and opinions that remain unchallenged or proven throughout the article.
Read moreFailure to give Islamophobia as much attention as antisemitism
"I understand that journalists choose the scope of their piece. What concerns me is that you do include Islamophobia in the scope of your article, but fail to give it near as much attention as antisemitism. I think it is important, at the very least, we hear from people who can speak about Islamophobia and anti-Palestinian racism."
Read moreCorrection needed to contextualize the situation in Gaza and add pro-Palestinian voices
"I insist that you add, at the very least, elements of context about the situation in Gaza, such as the ICJ ruling, Canada’s obligations under international law, and pro-Palestinian voices, to make your article balanced and for your readers to properly understand why this motion comes at such a pressing time."
Read moreThanks for portraying the exhaustion felt by Palestinians and amplifying their voices
"I particularly appreciated your efforts in presenting real-life experiences and amplifying the voices of Palestinians, including children who have been traumatized by Israel’s military campaign. Your portrayal of the exhaustion and strain felt by all, including medical personnel, was spot on."
Read more