Article unfairly frames pro-palestinian protest at Mcgill university
"There is a chasm between the phrases “Israel’s offensive” and “ongoing genocide.” I believe that many demonstrators would disagree that your description of their demands is even accurate, as opposing a military offensive is different than opposing plausible accusations of genocide."
Read moreCBC makes sweeping generalizations to describe Israel’s view of the Nakba
"It is critical that CBC not use sweeping generalizations to describe Israel’s view of the Nakba and provide at least some acknowledgment of the diverse views within Israeli society."
Read moreCTV News and CBC News admit that McGill refuses to share “video evidence” of alleged hate speech at protests
On April 29, 2024, CJPME sent letters to CTV News and CBC News, pushing the media outlets to add an important piece of information regarding articles (this one and this one) about the McGill encampments requesting their university’s full divestment from occupation and genocide.
CJPME wrote, among other things, that the articles quote the McGill administration’s claim that they have seen footage of people using antisemitic language and intimidating behaviour without clarifying if CTV News and CBC News requested to see the footage and if anyone at CTV News and CBC News has seen it.
CJPME insisted, among other things, that CTV News and CBC News clarify it they have seen the alleged video footage of antisemitic and intimidating behavior by protesters.
Following our letters, CBC News added the following sentence: “CBC News requested a copy of the video, but the university has not responded.” CTV News added the following sentence: “McGill University has not responded to CTV News Montreal's requests for interviews.”
While other issues were not acknowledged by CTV News and CBC News, this addition is necessary given the sensitive nature of these events and the numerous cases of false allegations of antisemitism on university campuses since protests began, this important piece of information can serve as a precedent to challenge other media outlets quoting McGill administration’s claim without verifying it.
Genocidal acts should not be described by terms like "attacks" or "war effort"
"Language is powerful and the words we use convey various meanings and emotions. The students participating in the encampment at McGill University have clearly and consistently used the word ‘genocide’ in their demands for the university to divest from corporations that are supporting or benefitting from Israel’s genocide on the people of Gaza."
Read moreArticle accuses pro-palestinian protests of being anti-semitic
"The protests are indeed targeting the actions and ongoing occupation of the Palestinian people by the Israeli government. However, they are not targeting Jewish Canadians. It would be similar to saying that the protests against the apartheid regime of the South Africa governments were targeting the citizens of South Africa and not the National Party government."
Read moreRe: “Jews have eyes. And they see that the antisemitism in the protests over Gaza is no aberration,” by Robyn Urback
The media’s favorite red herrings that distract from the undeniable truth of Gaza are becoming more than merely tasteless, but perpetuate the elongation of Canada’s complicity in real human suffering.
Read moreHave Canadian Press and Hamilton Spectator seen any of the alleged evidence of antisemitism at the McGill on-campus protest?
A Twitter thread shows a small sample of such examples, including pro-Israel students chanting anti-Semitic phrases, which were widely misreported as being a protest chant. While you do frame the claim as an allegation, it is unfortunate that an allegation without evidence is the lead into an article about a protest against genocide.
Read moreDescribing an encampment as a protest "in solidarity in Gaza" is inadequate
The violent police crackdown on the encampments across the US is imperative for Canadian readers to know, especially as a McGill encampment in Montreal emerges and takes root. Please elaborate on this unfortunate pattern that has been observed in the United States and Europe.
Read moreCBC should quote those who organize the encampments, not just those who condemn them
To consistently quote those who tend to condemn the protests/encampments but not those who organize them is illogical and journalistically irresponsible.
Read moreUrgent need to mention the genocide in Gaza and explain why Canadian students are encamping
"When you write that “University officials also said they saw video evidence of ‘some people using unequivocally antisemitic language and intimidating behaviour’ on campus,” it should be clarified if CBC has seen any of the alleged evidence. Given the sensitive nature of these events, CBC must be clearer on these points."
Read more