LATEST IMPACT: 2023-03-30 - Hamilton Spectator publishes letter from CJPME rebutting anti-Muslim and anti-Palestinian bigotry

On March 23, 2023, the Hamilton Spectator published a letter which made false charges against Ontario MPP Sarah Jama and Palestine solidarity activists, and reproduced anti-Muslim and anti-Palestinian bigotry. CJPME contacted the newspaper requesting that they retract the letter and remove an offensive quote from the subheading of the page. While the Hamilton Spectator declined to remove the letter, on March 30 they published an edited version of CJPME’s response, which reads:

Regarding ‘Jama and Stiles must go’ (March 23): The letter makes a false assertion that student groups in support of Palestine, as well as the Palestinian-led movement to boycott Israel (BDS), are seeking “the extermination of the state of Israel” and to “annihilate Jews living there.” To conflate a movement for Palestinian rights with violence against Jewish people is not only false and ignorant, it is cruel and defamatory.

The letter makes a false charge that Palestinian activists and slogans, including the BDS movement, are “Islamist.” However, most Palestinian movements (including BDS) are secular and encompass both Muslim and Christian Palestinians. The author is using the term “Islamist” solely to try to paint Jama and the Palestinian solidarity movement in a negative light, perpetuating anti-Islam and anti-Palestinian sentiment.

Further, describing Jama as “Islamist” to paint her in a negative light, whether because of her Muslim faith or because of her support for Palestinians, is straightforward anti-Muslim bigotry.

Pushing for better Middle East coverage in Canadian Media!

The Media Accountability Project (MAP) is an initiative of Canadians for Justice and Peace in the Middle East (CJPME) and was created to encourage Canadian media to provide professional and fair-minded coverage on the Middle East, especially Palestine-Israel.  The work of the MAP is based on professionally recognized journalistic ethics, as established by the Canadian Association of Journalists (CAJ) and the Canadian Broadcast Standards Council, which direct journalists at all levels to provide accurate, fair, independent, transparent and diverse coverage.  Members of the Canadian public who wish to participate in the MAP's action alerts are invited to sign-up as "Media Responders."  Once registered, Media Responders will receive occasional emails encouraging them to follow up with a particular journalist or news outlet to demand improvemens to coverage.  Donate here to support our media accountability work!   

  • Latest from the blog

    Critical context omitted regarding Indonesia’s refusal to host Israel Under 20 soccer team

    "I also urge you to provide additional context regarding Israel’s military occupation and apartheid regime. More context will enable your reader to better understand that Indonesia’s refusal to host Israel’s Under 20 soccer team is based on support for Palestinian self-determination and anti-colonialism."
    Continue reading

    Re: “For this Canadian Jew, my relationship with Israel is complicated”

    “Speaking up” is not a “feel good” thing.  If she had done it right, Lederman would indeed have been vilified by her community.  If she had truly spoken out against racism and injustice in Israel, she would indeed have had her words co-opted by malefactors.  This is the price of standing up for your principles."
    Continue reading

    Israeli Official called 'activist' and all controversy omitted by Winnipeg Free Press

    "Noa Tishby is an Israeli government official. Israel’s Foreign Minister appointed Noa Tishby as the “Special Envoy for Combating Antisemitism and Delegitimization.” Again, this is an official role in the Israeli government. Tishby is not acting as an activist in her forthcoming talk in Winnipeg, but rather acting in her role as an Israeli Official."
    Continue reading

    Strong coverage of Palestinian concerns for right-wing policies pursued by the Israeli government

    "I was especially pleased to hear that the guest Michael Koplow of the Israel Policy Forum addressed how Palestinian citizens are impacted by policies pursued by the current right-wing Israeli government. I am appreciative that attention was brought towards the racist and inflammatory comments made by Minister Bezalel Smotrich about Palestinians but also the forced expulsions, and settlement activity ongoing in the occupied West Bank."
    Continue reading
  • Latest from the blog

    MAP ALERT!: The Manitoban prints two salient articles on Palestine

    On March 21, The Manitoban published two articles on Palestine. The first, “Support for Palestine is crucial” provides an impressive summary of recent Palestinian political history. The second, “Palestinian Awareness Week comes to U of M” describes the struggles Palestinian students and activists have been facing at the University of Manitoba. Printing both of these articles is worth applauding, especially given the contentious environment students are working in.
    Continue reading

    MAP ALERT!: Thanks for highlighting beauty of Palestine

    In an account of her travels in Palestine, Safiya Patel shares honest stories about her experiences, including interactions with Israeli soldiers and photographs that depict Palestinian architecture, culture, and some images of the occupation. A snapshot of the beauty of Palestine, as well as the travesty of life under brutal occupation, are effectively captured in words and photographs. Her article, as well as The Varsity’s decision to publish it, deserve thanks.
    Continue reading