Melanie Lidman article, October 27

"I would encourage you in future reporting to reveal the full extent of Israel’s systemic cruelty and exceptionalism which runs to the core of its abhorrent supremacist world view."


To the Brandon Sun newsroom and Melanie Lidman,

I am writing on behalf of Canadians for Justice and Peace in the Middle East (CJPME) regarding your article “Opponents accuse Netanyahu of stoking tensions before vote” by Melanie Lidman published on October 27, 2026 in the Brandon Sun.

I thank you for this article that does not hide the fact that the current Israeli elections will result in nothing more than new faces executing the same policies regarding the racist and genocidal treatment of Palestinians and aggression towards neighboring states. 

I would like to offer a few points of feedback for you. The Palestinians quoted at the end of the article state the reality of the situation quite clearly. What’s missing is the degree of barbarity that is normalized in Israel. A country where Arab electoral participation and organization is routinely suppressed or disqualified.

Gadi Eisenkot mentioned in your article is certainly the same as Netauyahu as stated by Ibrahim Qeshta from Rafah. In fact Eisenkot could turn out to be even worse. He is a champion of the Dahiya Doctrine and has shown flagrant disregard for international law, like Netanyahu.

I would encourage you in future reporting to reveal the full extent of Israel’s systemic cruelty and exceptionalism which runs to the core of its abhorrent supremacist world view.

Thank you for reading and I look forward to your response.

Sincerely,

Jeff Winch, CJPME Media Analyst