"Please continue to publish articles that provide your readers with a deeper understanding of Palestinians, the reality of their daily lives and their longing for freedom, dignity, and peace."
Dear Mr. Selby, Mr Rodgers and Ms. Koran,
On behalf of Canadians for Justice and Peace in the Middle East (CJPME), I am writing to express gratitude for Booknotes: From the Ashes, the Phoenix Rises that was published on November 10, 2026 in the Kimberley Bulletin.
First of all, thank you for providing space in the article for Omar Hamad and Ibrahim Massir to share their perspectives. Palestinian voices are often omitted or minimalized in media reports but that was not the case here. Without question, Omar and Ibrahim’s dedication to building the Phoenix Library represented much more than assembling books. It represented their love of learning and a commitment to providing the opportunity for members of their community to read, to learn, to hope and to imagine.
The opening of the Phoenix Library is even more amazing given that they made it happen in the midst of an ongoing genocide and a land, air and sea blockade by Israel. Thank you for acknowledging that.
I live down the street from the public library here in Kelowna. I know that public libraries offer far more than access to books but also serve as community hubs for learning and support for people of all ages and places in our society. The role of the Phoenix Library is no different for the Palestinians living in Gaza. However, it also serves as one of the few places of ‘refuge’ and respite from the ongoing realities of and devastation in their daily lives.
The closing words of your article reminded me of the words of Usama. He is a Palestinian father and tour guide living in Bethlehem in the occupied West Bank of Palestine: “We just want to live a normal life, raise our children, work, welcome friends, and enjoy the simple things without fear or uncertainty”. The Phoenix Library is a glimmer of light to “life as it should be” or as in Usama’s words, ‘a normal life’.
Please continue to publish articles that provide your readers with a deeper understanding of Palestinians, the reality of their daily lives and their longing for freedom, dignity, and peace.
Sincerely,
Debbie Hubbard
Kelowna, British Columbia
