Why was there no effort made to contact one of the major human rights organization in Canada for this story?
To the Globe and Mail and Steven Chase,
I am writing on behalf of Canadians for Justice and Peace in the Middle East (CJPME) regarding your article “Strategic autonomy is the new Carney foreign policy. Where does that leave human rights?” by Steven Chase published on November 2, 2026 in the Globe and Mail.
I thank you for this article which is appropriately critical of Mark Carney’s trade deals first, human rights last approach to our relations with foreign nations. His “values based realism” is a convenient capitulation. It should be more accurately expressed as “greed based opportunism”.
Most Canadians would disagree with Carney’s new direction towards international trade. In a survey done this past spring over 85% of Canadians surveyed said human rights should be a concern when starting or maintaining trade relations with foreign countries.
Carney is now weaponizing trade and sovereignty disputes with the US to throw all decency and responsibility out of the window. One has to ask, according to Carney’s logic and practice, why not make deals with Russia? If this was 1938 would he be making deals with the Nazi regime in Germany?
Your examples of countries with poor human rights records, the UAE, Saudi Arabia and Turkey are all valid. The UAE in particular, as it funnels Canadian made weapons into Sudan to help the RSF facilitate a genocide there. The article also puts Russia and Israel together in the same sentence “But he’s refrained from targeting many countries beyond Israel or Russia with sustained public criticism.”
The two countries do not warrant this false equivalence. The Canadian government has imposed real sanctions on Russia yet virtually nothing substantive on Israel who are in their 4th year of genociding the Palestinian people. Our government has chosen to try and make the problem "extremist settlers” and have imposed no penalties whatsoever on the state of Israel itself. In fact we continue to share a trade agreement with Israel, CIFTA - business as usual. We have allowed Netanyahu to fly through our airspace despite arrest warrants from the ICC. So there is a blatant double standard at work here in Carney’s choices that deserves mention.
It is interesting that your article would mention a Turkish comedian’s conviction for insulting Erdogan yet not a word for the mass horrors in Gaza and now the West Bank which Canada supports.
It is also puzzling that Mr. Chase did not contact any human rights organizations for comment on this story. It would be an obvious choice to have their perspective included.
Why was there no effort made to contact one of the major human rights organization in Canada for this story?
Thank you for reading and I look forward to your response and answer to my question.
Sincerely,
Jeff Winch, CJPME Media Analyst
