Inadequate context and problematic language in news segment about a Palestinian death
"2023 has been the deadliest for Palestinians living in the West Bank in the last two decades, where at least 80 civilians including 17 children have been killed. Palestinians have been subjected to destructive and violent rampages by illegal Israeli settlers, often resulting in the destruction of Palestinian homes, businesses, and possessions. Palestinians also endure constant raids, arrests, and violence by Israeli forces. By referring to the escalation of violence in such generalized terms, you obscure the asymmetrical nature of Israeli violence on Palestinians."
Continue reading
News segment fails to mention the Nakba in coverage of Israeli "Independence day"
"The segment largely portrays Israel’s 75th anniversary as a celebration but without mentioning that it is also a day marking upheaval and tragedy for the Palestinian people. Indeed, this year also marks the 75th anniversary of the Nakba (Arabic for catastrophe), when Zionist forces forcibly expelled at least 700,000 Palestinians from their homes during the creation of Israel (1947-49). "
Continue reading
Thanks for including the Nakba in article about Israel's memorial day
"I appreciated that your article included a reference to the Nakba. Too often media reporting neglects to tell the complete story of Israel’s creation. For Palestinian citizens of Israel, the West Bank, East Jerusalem and Gaza, the creation of the state of Israel ‘was’ and ‘continues to be’ a ‘catastrophe’"
Continue reading
Re: "Happy 75th Israel!"
"Obadia asserts that Palestinian citizens of Israel have “the same inalienable rights as Jews.” In fact, Israel does not have a constitution, and instead operates on a number of “basic laws.” The absence of a constitution allows Israel to employ laws that are preferential to Israeli Jews and discriminatory towards Palestinian citizens of Israel, who are restricted in every aspect of life - immigration, employment, housing, healthcare, and family reunification."
Continue reading
No mention of Nakba, occupation or apartheid in article about Israel's Memorial day
"This framing presents Israel as a beleaguered country which has faced waves of violence, but fails to capture the extent to which Israel has been the aggressor power in the region. In particular, it does not mention that for the last 56-years Israel has been a belligerent occupying power over the Palestinian territories occupied since 1967 (the West Bank, East Jerusalem, and Gaza), as well as the occupied Syrian Golan Heights."
Continue reading
Inadequate context and unbalanced coverage in news segment about Palestinian casualty
"Unless the CBC considers injuries to five Israelis more important than the killing of one Palestinian, this omission is inexcusable. You should have also mentioned that Israel has maintained a brutal military occupation over Palestinians for 56 years. Such context is essential for listeners to understand that Palestinian violence is a direct result of raids, arrests, and violence by Israeli forces, not to mention destructive and violent rampages by illegal Israeli settlers."
Continue reading
Problematic and misleading language used to describe the 1948 Nakba
"To refer to the 1948 Nakba (catastrophe in Arabic) as a “Palestinian exodus” overlooks the fact that approximately 750,000 to 1 million Palestinians were expelled from their homes by Zionist militias and made refugees. Many are still refugees today, along with their families. They were forced to make a life for themselves elsewhere in the West Bank, Lebanon, Syria, and in Mr. Najjar’s case, Jordan."
Continue reading
Merci d'avoir dépeint à juste titre Itamar Ben-Gvir en tant que criminel, raciste, et extrémiste d’extrême droite
"Merci d'avoir dépeint à juste titre Itamar Ben-Gvir en tant que criminel, raciste, et extrémiste d’extrême droite ayant des liens avec des groupes terroristes sionistes. J'apprécie particulièrement que vous ayez inclus l'incident au cours duquel Gvir menace à main armée des résidents palestiniens."
Continue reading
False claim that Al-Aqsa Mosque is located in "Israel" by CP24
"Your news segment incorrectly refers to the prayers as taking place in 'Israel' when they are in occupied East Jerusalem, which is considered occupied Palestinian territory according to international law. This is not an opinion but a matter of settled consensus at the international level as confirmed by the United Nations Security Council, the International Criminal Court, the International Court of Justice, and the High Contracting Parties to the Fourth Geneva Convention. The official Canadian position, likewise, does not recognize Israeli control over East Jerusalem (including the old city and the Al Aqsa mosque.)"
Continue reading
Thanks for including segment on pro-Palestinian rally against Israeli violence
"Your interview with the rally organizer and activist Riyaz Khawaja was excellent. Often enough, Palestinian, and pro-Palestinian perspectives are silenced or deliberately left out of Canadian public discourse, especially when they challenge established power structures. Palestinians are engaged in a decades-long struggle for their liberation and human rights, and the media must be sure to include their narratives."
Continue reading
