Article accuses pro-palestinian protests of being anti-semitic
"The protests are indeed targeting the actions and ongoing occupation of the Palestinian people by the Israeli government. However, they are not targeting Jewish Canadians. It would be similar to saying that the protests against the apartheid regime of the South Africa governments were targeting the citizens of South Africa and not the National Party government."
Continue reading
Palestinians in Gaza were attacked and forcibly displaced, not fled the fighting
"Israel ordered over a million people in Gaza to relocate southward, compelling them to leave their homes. Therefore, their displacement was not a voluntary decision."
Continue reading
Israel is still the occupying power of the West Bank, East Jerusalem, and the Gaza Strip
"Experts including the United Nations fact-finding missions, Human Rights Watch, and the International Committee of the Red Cross concur that Israel's status as an occupying power persists. Under International Law, the designation of occupation does not rely on the presence of foreign ground troops within a territory, but rather on the assertion of 'effective control'."
Continue reading
Article should mention that MPP Sarah Jama was asked to remove her keffiyeh and that she defied the order to do it
"While you write that “keffiyehs have become somewhat of a political flashpoint in Ontario in recent weeks” and mention the debates at Queen’s Park and the motions to reverse the ban, you could have mentioned that MPP Sarah Jama was asked to remove her keffiyeh at Queen’s Park and that she defied the order to do it."
Continue reading
Urgent need to mention the genocide in Gaza and explain why Canadian students are encamping
"When you write that “University officials also said they saw video evidence of ‘some people using unequivocally antisemitic language and intimidating behaviour’ on campus,” it should be clarified if CBC has seen any of the alleged evidence. Given the sensitive nature of these events, CBC must be clearer on these points."
Continue reading
Condemnation of encampments is quoted in full, while organizers of encampment have their messaging paraphrased
"After all, Housefather’s condemnation of the encampment was quoted and fully embedded in the article. B’nai Brith’s was also quoted in full. To consistently quote those who condemn the protests/encampments but not those who organize them is illogical and journalistically irresponsible."
Continue reading
Concerns with article: has CTV seen footage of alleged McGill hate speech?
"The Canadian Association of Journalists strongly recommends additional care to these sorts of details be given in the context of reporting on sensitive or controversial issues. I hope that CTV News will take this feedback seriously in their ongoing coverage of Palestine solidarity encampments across Canada."
Continue reading
34,000 Palestinians have been killed by Israel, not by an unknown perpetrator
"To ensure balanced reporting and avoid double standards in your reporting, I, therefore, recommend explicitly stating that these Palestinians were killed by Israel. This adjustment would maintain accurate reporting and uphold the high standards of journalism expected by The Globe and Mail's readers."
Continue reading
Alarming one-sidedness on Israel-Hamas Conflict page
"These details are probably relevant for people to know. Why does a protester who was in a scuffle with a cop and allegedly fought back with a plastic straw deserve such outsized and one-sided media attention? That is a question Global News ought to offer. It is a sad day in Canadian media when plastic straw attacks garner significantly more media attention than plausible accusations of genocide."
Continue reading
"Cultural cloth" is not an adequate description of the keffiyeh
"Please update “the scarf,” “cultural cloth,” and “black and white checkered scarf” to simply “keffiyeh,” as it can be deeply offensive to Palestinians and their allies to use reductive terms to allude to the keffiyeh without providing any proper description of it, especially amidst the rise of anti-Palestinian racism."
Continue reading
